Steve Verno

By Steve Verno

Quality Medical Management/Emergency Medicine Specialists

View Bio

The Process of Disputing


 

I am a retired professor of medical coding and billing; I taught medical coding and billing at Everest University. I also worked for two large emergency physician practices, and one of my many jobs was to appeal denied medical claims. As a result, I learned all the ins and outs of the insurance companies, and I knew all their tricks. One thing to know about me is that I have always informed everyone in my many seminars and books that I am not a lawyer. I do not appeal. I leave that to the lawyers. What I do is simple: I dispute.

 

I have a simple process for disputing.

 

Firstly, I never dispute on the phone. The reason I don't use the phone is that a phone call offers no proof of what was presented and discussed. When you call, the insurance company can deny anything that was brought up during the call and, in some cases, that any call was made to the right person or department. Unfortunately, when they deny this, going to court or filing a complaint with state and federal agencies becomes incredibly difficult, if not impossible. Their denial has more weight than yours, as the burden of proof will be on you.

 

Therefore, I dispute in writing. On paper, you have evidence of who you are contacting, why you are contacting them, the evidence you are presenting, the rulings on why it should be paid, etc. You can use this to request that state and federal agencies require the insurance company to overturn their denial and pay the claim.

 

An important thing to remember about disputing is that you must leave emotion out of it and keep everything professional. What you write can (and will) be used against you.

 

Secondly, when I dispute, I go to the top of the food chain. I do not send a dispute to the claim address, which inevitably ends up in the mail room. This I know from personal experience. I spent a week at an insurance company's headquarters, and all the mail they received went to a small cubby on top of an abandoned desk, and after a week, every letter went into the trash can. I saw it with my own eyes. So, I send all disputes in writing via Certified Mail/ Return Receipt. This is proof that can be used for the regulatory and investigative agencies when the insurance company says they “never received anything.” My letter is sent directly to the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) at their corporate headquarters. It is important to note that the name of a CEO is not private. It is public information, and many insurance companies will post this on their website. Sometimes, I get this information from my State Division of Corporations, which every company must register. Another option is to refer to the Securities and Exchange Commission; look for a document called DEF-14. This document will tell you everything you need to know about an insurance company, down to the salary of the CEO.

 

When you compose your dispute letter, you must maintain professionalism. Stick to the facts: Patient, date of service, patient's health insurance information, claim submission date, claim denial date, claim denial reason, and applicable state and federal law.

 

It's important to note that, when you send a dispute letter, time is not on your side. The insurance company will do everything in their power to delay and, when delaying, they can go to the regulatory agencies and say, “Well, we contacted them for more information, but they never responded.” Most have senior officers whose sole job is to make you believe that they are your friend, dragging things out until the time limit has expired, and then the agencies will order you to write this off.

 

When I sent a dispute letter, and I had proof that it had been received, I gave them 14 calendar days to respond with a positive response. On the 15th day, I filed a complaint with the insurance commissioner and every regulatory agency. In my state of Florida, we have the State Insurance Commissioner, the Director of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, the Agency for Health Care Administration, the State Workers' Compensation Agency, the Department of Labor, and the Securities and Exchange Commission to include in those filings.

 

Now, importantly, they will call you to speak about the dispute, so it is vital that you ask them to put what it is they want to speak about in writing. Do not discuss anything over the phone! Remember, you need proof. If I ever received one of those calls and I recognized the number, I would send them directly to voicemail. Afterward, I would amp up my writing to the CEO. I never give up.

 

I've been doing this for decades, and I take my dispute knowledge and dispute my own medical bills, as well as personal banking and spending. I recently went up against a billion-dollar company and won my dispute using the same information and process that I'm writing about here. The only way it won't work is if you give up and you don't try.

 

In medical billing, you must be assertive, even aggressive at times, and you must fight back and represent your physician professionally. You must never give up or let the insurance companies dictate the terms of the dispute process. When you have the facts on your side, the evidence to show, and are willing to go to bat with them, they will have no choice but to respect you. The best medical biller that knows about disputes is our friend Don Self.

 

Once again: Be professional. Do not call; write! Dispute to the CEO. Dispute to the corporation headquarters, give them 14 days to respond, then file a complaint with regulatory agencies.

 

Never give up! Never surrender!

 

Source: Steve Verno is a (semi-retired) professor of medical coding and billing.

 

 

Was this article helpful?

Your feedback goes directly to our editorial team and helps us decide what to cover next.